Ensuring learning continuity for every African child in the time of COVID-19

Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, over 250 million primary and secondary children are out of school in Africa. If schools only reopen when normalcy returns, which is estimated to be in 2021 at the earliest, an inclusive learning approach that leaves no child behind, especially in Africa, is essential.

According to the World Bank, 87 percent of children in sub-Saharan Africa are learning poor and lack functional skills in a dynamic labor market. While the shutdown only creates a temporary out-of-school problem, prolonged closure can make being out of school permanent for some children, especially older ones that might be more easily lured into precarious job markets. This will add to the millions of children that were already out of school prior to the pandemic. Additionally, ancillary school services like school meals, sanitary pads, and immunization are disrupted while schools are closed.

The various stopgap measures to continue learning are not suitable for Africa and could in some instances amplify learning inequalities. Remote learning platforms require internet and hardware that are inaccessible to rural and poor households. In fact, a recent Brooking report estimated that less than 25 percent of low-income countries provided remote learning opportunities compared to about a 90 percent adoption rate in high-income countries.

Widely accessible mediums like radio and television are centered around mass education and will be difficult to target to children that are not learning under normal school settings. Sierra Leone’s experience with Ebola is instructive and points to the possible trajectory for other African countries with prolonged school closures. After eight months of closed schools, most children returned unable to recall material pre-Ebola, despite the use of radio and television mediums.

Based on what is known about COVID-19 and the effectiveness of social distancing in reducing its spread, a partial reopening of school can be implemented at no cost or disruption to flattening the curve. The optimal approach for reopening will be context specific, but here is a simple approach that illustrates the basic idea.

Let us imagine the most disadvantaged location with no access to digital platforms for personalized learning, which is reflective of many African regions. The approach is to open the school but replace face-to-face student-teacher interaction and regular school activities with contactless exchange of learning materials and progress.

Teachers will prepare the reading lists and assignments, while children simply pick up the daily task and submit the assignment from the previous day; school will serve as exchange, rather than meeting point. Based on grade, children might be allotted different times to avoid overcrowding and improve social distancing while ensuring more targeted learning. This simple cycle can be improved based on the reality on the ground. For example, targeted lessons can be given for children lagging behind.

The priority can be given to core academic subjects, such as mathematics and language, while other subject teachers in the interim act as assistants. The government can also recruit volunteers to assist teachers in implementing the plan, and the education workforce should be declared essential. Children can temporarily attend the school closest to their homes, and other costless adjustments should be considered.

This approach does not in any way preclude use of digital platforms, when and where available. With this arrangement, children can access other ancillary school services amid the pandemic.

MULTISTAKEHOLDER SUPPORT CAN MAKE THE APPROACH WORK

The government will be crucial to the successful implementation of this approach. Effective information sharing, investment, and purchase of learning materials are required, as is adequate sanitation of school premises. With appropriate copyright negotiation, learning materials can be mass produced using local resources. Mobilization of private sector resources and other innovative solutions is also needed. In all of this, peer learning about what works both within and outside a locality is essential.

Community and civil society also have a role to play. Through mobilizing local resources, they can help fill the likely financing gap for education, given the recent shock to government revenue. Their role in monitoring and evaluating both government support and school management and teachers’ activities could help drive success of the partial reopening. Community support will drive parents’ confidence in sending children to school.

The COVID-19 pandemic has made an already difficult task of providing inclusive and quality education for all even harder. The economic impact will be ephemeral as normalcy returns and economies grow again. However, the impact on education can be lifelong and irreversible for children who lose learning opportunities or completely drop out. For a continent with an enormous human capital deficit, learning cannot wait for complete normalcy to return and a partial reopening of schools will help in this regard.

This article was first published on Brookings

Read More

The Special Education Needs Of Violence-Induced Out-Of-School Children In Nigeria

The rise of Boko Haram has plunged North Eastern Nigeria, and particularly Borno State, deeper into educational crisis. While rebuilding infrastructure is already underway, and is certainly a good step, ensuring that the region is in a condition to recover must involve a much more careful and all-encompassing drive to ensure the state’s youth are given the opportunities every child needs and deserves.

The name ‘Boko Haram’—roughly translated as ‘Western/formal Education is sinful’—alone tells the story of the group’s position on formal education. While the numbers are tentative at best—Nigeria lacks sufficient disaggregated data for adequate appraisals of local situations—UNICEF estimated 1.8 million Borno State children remained out of school in 2016, largely owed to the presence of Boko Haram. The numbers are likely to have reduced since then, but the lack of reliable data makes the current damage difficult to estimate. Furthermore, the net-intake rate in Borno State—that is the number of children entering first grade at an age considered to be appropriate—stands at a measly 19%, and is amongst the lowest in the country.

Access to education according to the World Bank, “is a basic human right, and is central to unlocking human capabilities.” The current attack on educational opportunities in the North is certain to have long lasting ramifications on the prospects of the region’s development. Out-of-school children not only “face a higher risk of recruitment by armed groups, child marriage, early pregnancy and other forms of exploitation and abuse,” but also remain fundamentally ill-equipped to productively contribute to a post-conflict economy—further enhancing the malcontent that fuels tensions in the first place.

However, poor attendance is far from being the only problem facing the education sector in Nigeria, and more specifically in the North East. Learning poverty, a concept introduced by the World Bank to measure not just ‘quantity’ but also the quality of learning in developing countries, is rampant and damages the prospects of children irrespective of whether they succeed in attending school. For example, only 23% of the children in the North East that have attended formal school could read and comprehend a simple sentence either in English or local languages, highlighting how being in school, on its own, is not an automatic precursor to learning and human capital development.

The learning deficit experienced in the North-Eastern Region is placing its population at a severe disadvantage. Irrespective of whether children are able to attend school, without foundational learning of skills like reading and writing they will often fail to flourish later in life, whether in more advanced stages of their schooling or when they join the workforce. They thus fail to acquire the necessary human capital to have access to productive activities that can allow them to provide for their families, as well as engage as citizens in their communities. High learning poverty, therefore, is a structural obstacle to Nigeria’s progress towards achieving the Sustainable Development Goals given the integral nature of job creation, structural transformation, sustained growth and poverty reduction to Agenda 2030.

The Boko Haram Effect

While the causes of learning deficit in North Eastern Nigeria are undoubtedly diverse, the growth of Boko Haram over the last decade has given rise to a number of interrelated effects that are severely deleterious to the prospects of education for local youth, and underlie the damning statistics of learning paucity and regional inequality described above. A severe lack of access to schooling from violence and infrastructure destruction; poor teaching numbers and quality; insufficient managerial capacity to ensure the observance of standards; and an ill-conceived educational approach, are all exacerbated by the insecure climate in the states, and combine to create to learning crisis as witnessed in recent times.

It is estimated that Boko Haram has destroyed more than 5000 classrooms and school buildings in Borno State alone, systematically depleting the infrastructure required to extend education to communities particularly in rural, sparsely populated areas. To this end, the government’s drive to build “mega-schools” in the state to replace the lost infrastructure is certainly commendable.

Yet Boko Haram’s attack on schooling opportunities for Borno children goes beyond the destruction of infrastructure, and includes the creation of a climate of fear that shrouds the mere act of going to school in a veil of deep insecurity. Boko Haram’s abduction of 276 schoolgirls in the town of Chibok in Borno State was merely the most extreme and widely-reported symptom of a broader, often underappreciated threat: the methodical attack on schoolteachers and students to undermine the very institution of formal education. As of the end of 2018, more than 2300 teachers had been killed, aggravating the lack of avenues available to extend education to children across the region.

The killing of teachers is inextricably linked to the issue of learning poverty, and compounds with other factors to severely limit the effectiveness of teaching and education even when children are able to attend school. Not only has Boko Haram turned teaching into a dangerous profession, but it has also damaged the societal reputation of the profession. Fear of violence, and decreased reputational benefits of the job make hiring teachers committed to the betterment of the lives of their students increasingly difficult, which has led to a severe scarcity of teachers. The dearth of teachers, in turn, has led to a teacher-to-pupil ratio well below national guidelines thus damaging the classroom experience of children, so crucial in ensuring attendance translates into learning.

Malnutrition making children unable to learn; poor stimulation making them unwilling; poor teachers’ qualifications; lack of learning materials such as textbooks; unprofessional school management; and the lack of administrative capacity in education bureaucracies added to the low teacher numbers. These factor complement each other in determining poor learning outcomes, and must all be considered in addition to policies aimed at increasing attendance.

There is yet one more problem, however, that distinguishes youth development in conflict zones from other underdeveloped regions, and poses a challenge that extends much deeper than the all-too-common issues of low attendance and learning poverty. Children growing up surrounded by conflict are far more likely to develop psychological responses to trauma that greatly hinder their comprehension, ability to produce work, engagement in learning, and trust—all absolutely necessary in the education of a child. Without active focus on addressing the peculiarities of children exposed to violence, these children are far less likely to grow up to be positive, productive individuals in their society, oppositely exposing them to a life of criminality and compensatory violence.

Where we go from here

The multidimensional attack on education prospects of children in North Eastern Region requires a multi-pronged response. Again, the current government emphasis on rebuilding infrastructure, although necessary, is wholly insufficient if the ultimate target is to provide children with the opportunities required to grow up healthy, productive, and safe. The re-establishment of schooling facilities, therefore, must be complemented with a rigorous effort to end learning poverty, and ensure that children complete and leave school having learned the basic skills they will require. This will necessitate a drive to hire more qualified teachers which, again, may potentially be problematic given the adverse effects of the crisis on the motivation for teaching labour force. Hence, a concerted and well-thought out strategy—including perhaps financial incentives—to help make teaching a sufficiently attractive occupation will have to be developed. Furthermore, teachers are too often found to be insufficiently interested in the education of their pupils. Their lack of interest is exacerbated by an institutional lack of supervisory capacity, which therefore leave teachers unaccountable. Ensuring quality instruction requires effective supervision that will have to be part of the restructuring of education in affected region.

Improving numbers and commitment of teachers should be part of a more holistic attempt to improve  the classroom experience, which is a prime determinant of children’s learning. A wider focus to ensure children are well fed, healthy, and committed to education, and that the facilities at their disposal act as a conduit, not an obstacle, to their development cannot be taken for granted or relegated as secondary issues. The success of any education project must be measured in terms of learning outcomes, whose sufficiency can only be achieved in environments suited to learning. Concerns, pecuniary of otherwise, leading to a lack of focus on classroom experiences in favour of the mere access to schools must take into consideration that attendance alone does very little in guaranteeing the requisite education outcomes.

Above and beyond education policies suitable to any environment where schooling access and quality are lacking, children in North East Nigeria require a strong initiative that is tailored to the needs of the children of conflict. This must begin with a re-education of teachers in the skills needed to help pupils coming from traumatic experiences, which should be compounded with greater access to guidance counsellors trained in trauma recuperation. Building positive relationships, fostering positive emotions through positive priming, and teaching character strength have all been shown to be paramount to the recuperation of children who have suffered. Education system must go beyond teaching their students to read (in itself not so easy, as highlighted above), but must be well-suited to develop the types of relationships that “children of conflict” require.

While the physical interactions with teachers are the most important aspect in helping children exposed to trauma, the effort to ensure this focus must begin at the policymaking level. Affected states in the North Eastern Nigeria, as well as the relevant Federal Government agencies like the Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs and the North East Development Commission must first acknowledge the need for special education initiatives, and subsequently seek creative solutions. Creating an inclusive partnership with local and international partners as well as with education policy experts with the aim of training teachers, and designing appropriate curriculums, will be vital for the children in the Northern Nigeria.

While Boko Haram continues to wreak havoc in Northern Nigeria, the local population, and children in particular, will inevitably be denied access to an environment secure enough to permit their thriving. While some efforts to re-establish a semblance of educational normality have been made, the only hope for the region is a concerted and radical restructuring of the paradigm guiding the education of the youth. Only then will children be afforded the opportunities they need and deserve to build themselves a life befitting of their needs and the suited to a positive societal contribution.

Read More

Pan-African Scientific Research Council: Call for Expression of Interest

The COVID-19 pandemic has revealed the stark need for African institutions of higher education that can efficiently generate and transmit knowledge in times of crisis. Now more than ever, scientists and social scientists must come together to generate policy-relevant research. To fill this vital need, African researchers are forming a Pan-African Scientific Research Council on the premise that “Research is not a luxury, but rather a survival strategy.”

The Council was initiated by Leonard Wantchekon, Professor of Politics at Princeton University and the Founder and President of the African School of Economics (ASE), as part of his contribution to the ongoing global campaign to generate a robust and enduring international response to the Pandemic.

Click the link below to download the call for Expression of Interest.

Read More Download PDF Download PDF Download PDF

Some thoughts on new poverty numbers in Nigeria

With the recent release of the 2018/2019 Harmonized Nigeria Living Standard Survey (HNLS), the true scale and scope of poverty in Nigeria will become clearer. When the World Data Lab's Poverty Clock in 2018 released its poverty estimate which put Nigerian as the country with most extremely poor people, the federal government through the ministry of National Planning and Budget dismissed it saying ‘the National Bureau of Statistics is the statutory agency of government with responsibility for producing Nigeria’s official statistics, including poverty estimates.’ Finally, NBS-own estimate shows 82.9 million Nigeria, 40.1% of the population, live on less than ₦376.52 per day. This officially confirms Nigeria as the poverty capital of the world. Here are other notable highlights from the newly released poverty figure.

Poverty resides in rural areas in Nigeria. You are 65% more likely to be poor if you reside in a rural area. In addition, rural dwellers are farther below the poverty line relative to urban dweller (Figure 1). This means that the average urban poor person requires a smaller improvement in their consumption to cross the poverty line relative to rural dwellers. Specifically, the rural poor will require almost a threefold increase in their consumption just to be on par with the urban poor.

Figure 1: Depicting the poverty gap

Distinguishing those who are just a little away from the poverty line and those who are significantly away from the line.

Poverty does not obey federal character. Northern states have higher rates of poverty relative to Southern states. The poverty estimates from some states are worth highlighting. Sokoto state has the highest poverty rate in Nigeria at 87.73%. Lagos state has the lowest poverty rate in Nigeria. This seems not to be mainly driven by level of urbanization as Abuja, one of the major urban centers in Nigeria, has a poverty rate that is over 8 times that of Lagos.

Male headed households turn out to be consistently poorer than female headed households. Across all levels of disaggregation available in the preliminary report published by the NBS, female headed households tend to have lower poverty rates. Is there a selection issue with more empowered women heading the female headed household on average? We would have to wait for the complete dataset to study the mechanisms through which households’ outcomes differs based on the head’s sex.

Having at least a secondary education tends to beat living in an urban area without similar qualification in reducing the likelihood of living in poverty. Again, this observation is from simple descriptive analysis. The relative impact of education and residence on the likelihood of living in poverty will require more rigorous causal inference.

Smaller households are less likely to be poor relative to larger families. In fact, two out of three household with more than nine members turn out to be living in poverty. Conversely, only about one in five of the households with less than five members are considered poor.

Poverty is higher in revenue-dependent states. States that rely on Federation Account Allocation Committee (FAAC) allocations as their major source of revenues tend to have higher poverty (Figure 2). Lower internally generated revenue (IGR) signals low levels of economic activities within a state as well as weak state capacity. None of the nine oil producing states recorded a poverty rate of up to 31%, again underscoring the importance of state capacity.

Figure 2: Higher poverty in revenue-dependent states

What to make of the numbers?

The preceding analysis is based on descriptive summaries provided by the NBS. A full report and accompanying micro dataset, which should be published soon, will provide better opportunity for generating clearer insights. However, the following recommendations follow from the preliminary analysis.

  • The rural-urban divide in poverty rates signals that poverty can be reduced by either developing the rural areas into urban centres or encouraging rural-urban migration. The latter seems like a less daunting task to undertake in the short term. However, a more enduring solution lies in development of a comprehensive rural development programme that effectively link economic transformation between rural and urban areas. Low hanging fruits such as improving the availability of agricultural inputs and infusing productivity-enhancing farming practices through extension workers can work wonders for Nigeria’s food security, nutrition, and rural poverty reduction. 
  • Educate rural girls! Only 10.15% of female headed rural households with post-secondary education live in poverty compared to 31.2% of male headed households with similar qualification. This pattern is observed throughout the data, signalling the impact of education on households’ outcomes. If you are looking for an intervention that can produce massive multidimensional impacts, you do not need to look beyond girl child education.
  • Promote family planning and encourage smaller household sizes. The preceding analysis indicates that larger household sizes are a good predictor of poverty in Nigeria even if we may be led to believe that things get ‘cheaper by the dozen’. Promoting family planning should be an integral part of the government’s poverty reduction strategy.
  • Make it easier for MSMEs to operate. A list of recommendations for improving development outcomes in Nigeria will not be complete without stressing the need to improve the conditions within which businesses operate. So, plug the normal trope about power, credit, other infrastructure, etc. here yourself.

This article was written by Joseph Ishaku and Adedeji Adeniran

Read More

Why Effective Communication Is Fundamental To The Fight Against Covid 19 In Nigeria

The odds are that the world will defeat the Covid-19 pandemic in the end – prospects of an eventual vaccine are promising; and fatality rates, while devastating, have remained on the lower end of total population sizes. The question is how much of a toll Covid-19 will extract from humanity, before we eventually overcome it. Losses in human lives and economic capital across the globe so far are already monumental – and still on a rise in regions like Africa. The truth is that an extremely difficult road still lies ahead for mankind, in this time when, like never before in recent history, we all face this common, fatal threat. However, if we handle the situation and ourselves the right way, we will get to the end of that road sooner rather than later. It has already been seen, in places like Taiwan, that timely action is a far greater panacea than much else – by making simple, necessary adjustments to civil existence, sometimes merely weeks beforehand, a great number of lives have been saved. Infection-rates in other places have progressively declined, from concerted and sustained efforts between government and citizenry. The point is that, with no cure at hand, the world has so far fought this disease primarily with information – information about the physical mechanisms of spread so that we may act pre-emptively against it, and information about who has been infected and who is likely to have been, so that they may be separated from everyone else, for instance.

Countries that appear to be winning the fight are on this track because they have weaponized vital information – from administrative levels to groups, down to the single individual. Nevertheless, the information in and of itself is not enough – as a matter of fact, information in a time such as this could be dangerous even…the wrong sort, that is. For instance, the proliferation of misinformation during this pandemic, in what the World Health Organization (WHO) has termed an infodemic, has exacerbated the situation in different ways. What is ideal is for useful and accurate information to be relayed at the right time and in the right way, such that all of whom require it will receive and sufficiently comprehend it in order to act upon it, in the manner that is demanded. This is effective communication.

With rising numbers of infected across Africa, it would appear that the continent is losing the battle so far. The problem is not in the dearth or reach of information about the pandemic; a lot of what is happening is predicated on how, even when essential information is available, it is not communicated effectively enough. Take for instance the Nigerian conundrum – while aware of the pandemic, the vast majority of people are far more concerned about the difficult economic conditions they live in. Many Nigerians expressed opposition to the lockdowns imposed by the government to curb disease-spread, for the limitation to their livelihoods; and generally consider hunger a more present and daunting threat to themselves than the Coronavirus.

 When on May 4th, 2020, lockdown measures were eased in affected states, scenes of overly crowded public places where replete on the same day, setting the stage for an explosion of infections. The widespread and wanton disregard of a very dangerous situation in this case ultimately rests on a failure to communicate the severity of the imminent threat effectively to everyone concerned, by the parties that should. There are many Nigerians who have heard about the Coronavirus, but who just do not understand or fear it sufficiently enough to do what is required without coercion. There are even many Nigerians who, sadly, still believe the virus does not exist. Then again, there are those who are more engaged by conspiracy theories about its origin, and unfounded information about its cure, than in scientifically established methods for its prevention.

Short of coming to a time when fatalities from the disease abound, a time when we would be facing the worst possible scenario of the crisis, millions in Nigeria will not comprehend the situation well enough to play their part fully. For the ones who are better-informed, it is impossible to disregard the fact of any disease-related ignorance among the masses without consequence, because in the web of this pandemic, everyone is endangered by the wrong actions of everyone else. The man who has self-isolated for 5 weeks will still be infected when a nonchalant passer-by sneezes close to him while on his evening run; the essential worker observing every precaution in her duties will still be put in jeopardy by a throng of clients not wearing adequate protective clothing; and the unwitting, untested entrant will still introduce the virus into a community that has managed thus far to remain without it, by travelling there from somewhere else. For the collective good, it is cardinal that effective communication is deployed so that every person fully grasps our current, shared predicament; as well as their individual role in driving the solutions to it.

THE RIGHT KIND OF INFORMATION

Clearly, it is not enough to say to the average Nigerian, “There is a deadly Coronavirus pandemic afoot. Everyone ought to stay home, and practice social distancing when out”. In another environment perhaps, this is a strong enough warning to induce acquiescence. However, in this context, it is entirely possible that the trauma of daily existence for the very indigent majority requires a far graver tone of threat, in order for the gravity not to be drowned out. The same man for instance, who listens to the news on the radio in the morning about increased numbers of infected, and who subsequently converse about the same with his wife, will get on a crowded bus shortly afterward, without a facemask, and go to physically interact with numerous people at his work in a crowded marketplace. For him, his inability to provide for his family that day amidst their penury will kill them quicker than any virus could. While no one wants to create a panic or worsen an existing one, it is increasingly apparent that to spur Nigerians to the right action, it is necessary to cause them to be adequately concerned about their lives, and the lives of everyone around them. At this critical time, perhaps conversations should commence, on how to acceptably adapt public information on the pandemic to the more socially grim Nigerian context, so that the full extent of the danger is universally appreciated.

ENGAGE COMMUNITIES, TAILORING INFORMATION TO THEM

The majority of Nigerians live under the poverty line. As such, access to (and comprehension of the content of) conventional news media is often limited. Information around the novel Coronavirus should be tailored specifically to lower income groups, and delivered directly to their environments. Communication should be widespread and interactive, so that everyone receives every pertinent detail in equal measure, and is able to clarify their understanding of the situation. Many individuals and groups have in recent times shown admirable altruism in reaching out to the economically disadvantaged with food and other resources in this pandemic; information is just as vital, and these outreaches as well as the ones to come should prioritize enlightening the lower classes about the pandemic, in the most fitting ways.

EVERYONE IS INVOLVED

Similar to retrofitting automobile factories to produce ventilators in response to this crisis, the situation requires parties that hold platforms for communicating with meaningful population sizes to leverage this reach and disseminate appropriate information about the pandemic. In addition to traditional information media, thought and religious leaders, public personalities, social groups and other organisations would do well to interact with their audiences and convey the relevant information around the crisis, and do this in ways that guarantee that the recipients gain full insight. It helps to speak in local languages for instance or to enact the threat in relatable terms. For the individual citizen, it is critical to understand just how deleterious misinformation could be in this current panic-riddled atmosphere; and for this reason not to engage or disperse any unverified information. The task ahead can only be taken on with any success if we all act in concord.

"In light of recent events and ongoing developments around the World, due the CoronaVirus pandemic, CSEA will continue to provide perspectives ,and policy options by contextualizing current trends and the probable impact of this crisis on Nigeria’s economy".


Read More