Invest in Nigeria’s Most Valuable Resource

Human development indicators show that Nigeria does not adequately invest in its people. Nigeria continues to perform abysmally in key health and education indicators. The country is the Download File">second largest contributor to the world’s maternal mortality rate. Worse still, pregnant women are not the only ones faced with this bleak reality as the average Nigerian is expected to die at Download File">age 53. On education, Download File">10.5 million children are not enrolled in school, the world’s highest number of out-of-school children, and Download PDF">four out of five children who have completed primary education cannot read.

The country’s low human capital has caught the attention of philanthropists: the founders of the Download File">Tony Elumelu Foundation, Dangote Foundation, and more recently, Download File">Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. While at the National Economic Council in March 2018, Bill Gates, co-founder of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation pointed out that the government’s low investment in the education and health sectors has contributed to these poor outcomes. In 2018, the proposed national budget for education as a percentage of GDP is a meagre 0.005 percent which is a significant shortfall from the UN-recommended 6 percent. In the same year, the budget share for health stood at 4 percent, significantly lower than the AU-recommended 15 percent.

However, increased funding is not the sole pathway to positive outcomes in these sectors. According to Gates, availability of facilities, stock of medicine and equipment, among other non-financing mechanisms, are equally critical in achieving improvements in the health sector. A Download File">paper by my colleague, Joseph Ishaku, shares the same opinion. The study shows the importance of school quality - class size, textbook availability, school organization, and feeding programme – in the learning outcomes of children.

Alternatives to Increased Funding

With the same funding, the government can deliver better education and health outcomes by leveraging on the skills and resources of relevant stakeholders. Partnerships with the private sector, donor community and development institutions will share risks and expertise, promote coordination and prevent duplication of efforts. On education, Abia state is a notable example on public-private partnerships. Abia, which has topped WAEC results across the country for three years (2015, 2016 and 2017) in a row, adopted the Download File">Friends of Abia School Adoption Initiative (FASAI) in 2015. Through FASAI, indigenes of the state contribute to the state’s educational system by paying for the fees of school children and/or renovating school buildings.

Infusing technology is another means to help the government accomplish more for less. In the health sector, technology can aid in providing access to healthcare services in rural areas and fragile zones, curtail diagnostic errors and reduce mortality. In 2009, Ondo state government demonstrated how technology can be deployed to solve a health problem. The government initiated the Download File">Abiye (Safe Motherhood) Program which offered cell phones to expectant mothers in order to connect them to health workers, increasing skilled-attendance of birth by fifteen-folds.

Lastly, improved data collection is critical in deploying proven methods rather than wasting time and resources by reinventing the wheel. Establishing a unified data collection system at both federal and state levels will aid in making fact-based decisions, utilize scarce resources more efficiently and track improvement in outcomes.

According to economic theory, investments in human capital – skills, knowledge and health of people - is essential to a country’s economic growth process. U.S. history tells the story of how five men - Download File">Cornelius Vanderbilt, John D. Rockefeller, Andrew Carnegie, J. P. Morgan, Thomas Edison and Henry Ford –  and their workers transformed the U.S. into a global super power. Chinese entrepreneurs, in part, transformed the former communist nation to capitalism, turning China into the second biggest global economy. Nigeria with its young population structure (over half of the population is below age 18) stands a great chance of reaping significant demographic dividends if its citizens are productive and actively participate in the economy. Investments in education and health sectors will develop Nigeria’s most valuable resource – the Nigerian people - and engender long-term economic growth.

Read More

3 Things You Need to Know About The Economic Implications of Budget Delay

Public budget is an estimate of government expenditures and revenues for a financial year. It is a tool of economic planning and fiscal policy. It is also a key tool for the government to control the direction of the economy, and attain greater efficiency. To meet this goal, governments usually operate within a defined time horizon, otherwise known as a budgetary calendar. In Nigeria, public budgeting is supposed to start on January 1 and end on December 31. This means that a budget proposal should have been approved by the National Assembly and assented to by the President before the beginning of a New Year. The 2018 Budget proposal was delivered by President Muhammadu Buhari to the National Assembly on November 7, 2017.  However, up to present moment, the 2018 budget has not yet been passed. This undoubtedly, has adverse implications on the Nigerian economy in three main ways:
  1. Stifling of economic growth: Firstly, government spending contributes directly to the economy through transfers and capital expenditures. This means that a delay in budget implementation would reduce government’s contribution to economic growth. Secondly, the government’s plan on revenue generation and expenditures (otherwise known as fiscal policy), influences other economic agent decisions like whether government is going to spend more (expansionary) or spend less (contractionary). A budget delay would therefore bring about uncertainty in the government fiscal policy direction. Thirdly, budget delay only affects capital expenditure such as infrastructural development. It doesn’t affect recurrent expenditures like payment of salaries. This means that infrastructural development such as building of hospitals, schools, construction of roads etc. would be significantly constrained.
  2. Poor budget implementation: It is quite logical to also expect that budget delay would bring about poor budget implementation. For example, Projects may be carried out haphazardly in order to meet up with the expected time. Additionally, budget delays introduces lack of accountability into the budget process, which could lead into diversion of public resources.
  3. Negative impact on Domestic investment: Budget delay brings uncertainty not just on the Government’s fiscal policy direction, but also on the decisions of the private sector. Since the private sector play a critical role in job creation, budget delay would indirectly affect employment level. For Nigeria, with an unemployed population of over 15.9 million people, budget delay further complicates the problem.
Budget delay is not without negative economic implications on both the public and private sectors. Policymakers must ensure a standardized budgetary calendar. This is the only way to deliver effectively on government’s plan and positively influence economic growth. (This blog post is from an Opinion Article by CSEA's Senior Research Fellow, Download File">Adedeji Adeniran and Research Associate, Download File">Samuel Bodunrin. Click Download File">here to read more)  
Read More

The Economic Effect of Budget Delay in Nigeria

Public budget plays a crucial role in economic management and broader development policies. Importantly, it is the main transmission mechanism of fiscal policy and the key tool through which government could stabilize and influence the economic direction. Global experience in public budgeting indicates that countries adopt a defined time horizon or standardized budgetary calendar. The budgetary calendar does not necessary synchronize with the Gregorian dating but only requires a fixed start and end periods for each fiscal cycle. The importance of having budgetary calendar is to reduce uncertainty that could affect optimization behavior and expectation of economic dramatic personae.  The rigid time frame also ensures discipline and enhances coordination.

In the case of Nigeria, public budgeting is expected to follow the Gregorian dating, beginning on January 1 and ending on December, 31. Based on Section 82.1 of the 1999 constitution, it is anticipated that appropriation bill will have been passed before the beginning of a financial year. In fact, the constitution considers delay in budget passage as an aberration, such that new government expenditure is restricted and only functional spending, which is fixed to the corresponding period estimate, is  allowed. However, in the past two decades of democratic governance in Nigeria, budget delay has become a norm, with the standardized budgetary calendar adhered to only twice in the past twenty years. In this piece, we shed light on economic impact of budget delay, to highlight on an important area for public sector reform.

The Nigerian budget cycle and the source of budget delay

The budget cycle starts with the executive articulating its vision and plan for the economy to the Ministry of Finance (MoF) and the Budget Office of the Federation (BOF) through the medium-term fiscal framework. Depending on the division of functions, the MoF and Ministry of Budget and Planning alternate this role. After this, the BOF and MoF introduce a form of transparency by involving stakeholders such as NASS, the National Economic Council organized private sector, Civil Society and Public Sector through series of interactive sessions. Through this multi-stakeholder process, the revenue is estimated and MDAs expenditure ceilings are set. Thereafter, the FMF circulates the Budget Call Circular in June of each year, which is a formal invitation for MDAs to begin budget submission.

Figure 1 shows how budget proceeds from the stage when the MDAs submit their estimates, in line with zero-based budgeting. All submissions are evaluated and consolidated by the BOF and the draft is presented to the President and the Federal Executive Council for approval. The proposed budget is then submitted by the President to the National Assembly for review, deliberations and approval around October of each year. The budget is at this stage scrutinized and evaluated separately by the Senate and Representatives through debates and various committees. However, there is no time limit for the National Assembly to draw up the final budget. Final phase involves the assent of the appropriation bill and implementation by the executive.

Figure 1: Nigerian budget process

 

" alt="" width="1017" height="522">

The budget process in Nigeria has never been as smooth as expected. The cause of the delay is multifaceted. However, the budget is substantially delayed at the legislative action phase. This is because the two legislative layers separately review the budget and subsequently harmonize it into a single budget document. Also, disagreement between the legislature and executive on the expenditure items and level could drag the process, playing back-and-forth between the legislative action and the final phase.

Measuring the cost of delay

To provide a sense of economic impact of budget delay, we compare economic growth in quarter(s) before and after budget is passed. The rationale is that if budget delay is costless, growth in the two periods should not be significantly different. The result is shown in Figure 2. We interrogate the economic effect further by fitting the trend line and deriving the regression coefficients between budget delay and various economic outcomes. The results are graphical displayed using scatter diagram in Figure 3 Budget delay is measured by numbers of days between January, 1 and the when the President assented the budget. Also, we focus on four economic outcomes: GDP growth, FDI growth, domestic investment growth and the percentage of budget implementation. The analysis covers 2000 to 2017, the entire fourth republic.

Figure 2: Comparison of economic growth in quarters before and after budget signing

" alt="" width="1024" height="748">

Data source: NBS, 2018 and Authors compilation

Figure 3: Scatter diagram of Budget delay and GDP growth, FDI, Domestic Investment and budget Implementation

" alt="" width="1024" height="750">

Data source: NBS, 2018 and Authors compilation

The emerging facts

Based on analysis in Figures 2 and 3, the following observations can be drawn on the economic cost of budget delay:

  • Budget delay impacts negatively on economic growth: We found an inverse relationship (-0.025) between the budget delays and economic growth. Specifically, a 100 days delay in the budget implementation tends to depress the economy by 2.5 percent. Similarly, a comparison of quarterly performance indicates growth is higher by about 1.82 percentage point in quarters after budget passage than before. Several factors could explain this trend. First, government contributes directly to economy through government spending (transfers and capital expenditure), which means that budget delay depresses its contribution to GDP. Second, other economic agent decisions are influence by government fiscal plan, whether expansionary or contractionary policy. Uncertainty on government policy direction therefore amplify the economic cost due to the delay. Lastly, budget delay only affects capital expenditure, as recurrent expenditure falls within functional activities. This means infrastructural development which is a key enabler for economic growth will be significantly constrained.
  • Budget delay leads to poor budget implementation: Unsurprisingly, the poor implementation are more pronounced in fiscal years with considerable budget delay. A negative correlation coefficient of -0.001 was found between budget delay and percentage of budget implementation. Poor budget implementation no doubt at the root cause of poor service delivery. Budget delay also introduces opacity into the budget process, which could induce diversion of public resources.
  • Domestic investment is negatively affected: The analysis also finds a negative relationship (-0.040) between domestic investment and budget delay. One explanation for this is the uncertainty induced by budget delay on decision and expectation of private sector. In addition, given the crucial role the private sector plays in job creation, the budget delay indirectly affects employment level.

Conclusion

Public budget is an important policy document that provides a roadmap for government activities and programmes for a fiscal year. To meet this goal, it needs to operate within a define time horizon and engender economic stability. Nigeria’s experience of endlessly dragging the budget process has needlessly imposed substantial economic costs on the public and private sectors. The policy implication is obvious—policymakers must ensure a standardized budgetary calendar. Less obvious is whether there is an alignment of political interests to realize it. It is not clear who benefits from the delay, but budget actors seem to stall the process in a ‘war of attrition’ to maximize their benefits. Essentially, budget delay reflects the power and interest frictions among political actors. In this respect, it might be exigent for Nigerian fiscal rule to be broadened to also include a mandatory standardized budgetary calendar and a define timeframe for each budget process

Read More