Following FACTS to Recover and Revamp Nigeria’s Education System During and Beyond COVID-19

Before the Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic stalled learning for students in Nigeria, the nation’s education system was facing an epidemic of its own: a deeply inadequate and inequitable education system that taught far too little to only a few students. At the peak of the pandemic, almost 40 million students were affected by the nationwide school closures, but even prior to this, Nigeria suffered from the highest proportion of out-of-school children worldwide. And, for those that were enrolled, there is overwhelming evidence that learning levels were much lower than expected. With the current second wave of the virus, school holidays have been prolonged, suggesting a continued stall in learning for children.

In this brief, we highlight a simple and smart approach to recover the expected learning loss and revamp Nigeria’s education system, conveniently summarized in the acronym FACTS: Foundational learning, Assessment, Curriculum alignment, Technology and Special needs.

Pre-Pandemic Learning Levels

According to a 2015 National Education Data Survey (NEDS) which assessed literacy and numeracy levels, 46 percent of children enrolled in primary school could not identify words, read a single short sentence, or demonstrate basic comprehension in English or any of Nigeria’s three main native languages. In terms of numeracy, 35 percent were unable to add two single-digit numbers which summed to less than 10. In addition, there are huge variations along key demographic characteristics. According to the NEDS study, approximately 14 percent of the lowest wealth quintile showed minimum learning competencies in literacy and numeracy, compared to 82 percent and 84 percent of the highest quintile in literacy and numeracy respectively. Students in private primary schools achieved 74 percent and 84 percent literacy and numeracy competencies, while students in public schools achieved 44 percent and 56 percent, respectively.

Pandemic-Induced Learning Losses

Though schools have been allowed to reopen since September 2020, it is difficult to decipher the accrued learning loss induced by the school closures in Nigeria because there is no evidence that any assessments have been done either nationally or at state levels to determine how far behind students are. However, what we do know is that merely returning to schools and maintaining the pre-COVID status quo will not recoup the learning losses or avoid the associated lifetime and economic losses induced by the school closures. According to a  recent simulation exercise by Belafi and Kaffenberger, without any forms of remediation, a 6-month school closure, as was the case with Nigeria, will result in an average loss of 1.4 years worth of learning for the current cohort of primary school students. With some remediation, this learning loss only reduces slightly to 1 year. On the other hand, they also show that an intervention focused on long-term reorientation of the education system will lead to a learning gain of about 7 months, generating not only learning recovery but further gain.

This is further entrenched by the fact that schools across the country moved students on to the next school year upon resumption, despite students missing a full term and a half of the previous year. As evidence shows, students had different levels of access to remote learning during the school closures, signifying that students will be returning to school with differing levels of skills and knowledge.

The state of Nigeria’s pre-pandemic education, compounded by the impacts of the pandemic, calls for more than a resumption of normality. While a variety of approaches could be implemented to achieve this, it is crucial to draw on available evidence that aligns to the facts of Nigeria’s education system in designing such long-term reorientation plans. Below, we draw on the available evidence to highlight five crucial approaches required for an innovative learning system that is suited to achieving the dual goal of recovering and revamping the nation’s education system.

FACTS: Foundational learning, Assessment, Curriculum alignment, Technology and Special needs

F- Foundation learning

Foundational learning focuses on reading and comprehension (in the language of the learner’s immediate environment) and arithmetic, crucial to enabling students to learn in subsequent grades and preparing them for careers after school. Typical school schedules and curricula in Nigeria consist of foundational learning plus other school subjects. However, given the time and learning lost to COVID-19, at least the next two school calendars should place greater focus on foundational learning. Weakness in foundational learning is at the crux of Nigeria’s poor performance in education, as it serves as the gateway to knowledge acquisition in other subject areas. It is therefore essential that it be made the cornerstone of any strategy to address Nigerian education’s inadequacies in the immediate and longer term.

 A- Assessment

As schools reopen, there is a need to know how far behind students are and how fast they are recovering in all subjects. Assessments put the focus directly on learning, as it provides evidence of the skills and knowledge students have, which allows decision makers to make better evaluative judgments on how to support learning recovery and make advancement toward learning goals. A combination of frequent, low-stakes, formative assessments at the school level, and nationwide school surveys are crucial to provide feedback that inform swift, targeted, and locally-relevant responses must be prioritized. Conversely, high-stakes examinations at the end of the school term should be postponed until recovery from learning loss to prevent unjust penalties for vulnerable groups that have been disproportionately impacted.

C- Curriculum Alignment

School systems in Nigeria are mostly organized by grades, with teaching targeted at grade or age levels. However, the key to learning recovery in Nigeria is the alignment of teaching and instructional support to where students are in their learning trajectory. Teaching at  the skill-level of different learners has been shown to yield substantial learning gains, and a benefit of frequent school level assessments is that it provides the evidence that allows schools to adapt curricula to this proven approach in order to best help students recover learning losses. 

T- Technology

Advances in technology have sparked a paradigm shift in education by breaking down geographical barriers, expanding the quantity, and improving the quality of learning. However, while school closures induced by the pandemic have resulted in a surge in the development and uptake of educational technology around the world, geographic barriers have given way to digital barriers, with most schools and families unable to leverage technology for learning. Given Nigeria’s socio-economic disparities and poor infrastructure, educational technology will not work in isolation. With the onset of this second wave of the virus, it is imperative that policymakers begin to consider alternative learning options by working with research and development partners to pilot and rigorously test the effectiveness of blended learning approaches tailored to different regional contexts and aligned with different profiles of deprived learners and under-resourced learning environments. Innovative approaches to incorporate learning technologies that are cognizant of infrastructural disparities will be crucial to ensure a variety of learners can take advantage of mixed in-person and remote opportunities suited to their needs.

S-Special needs

Given inequalities in learning levels for students that experience various dimensions of poverty and exclusion, it is important to prioritize the learning needs of the most vulnerable and at-risk children as they are likely to require the most investment to recover from learning losses in the previous academic year, as well as additional non-academic support, including material and psycho-social, to ensure they are equipped to learn. Prioritizing the needs of vulnerable students is critical for Nigeria’s education system to make an inclusive and equitable recovery and build the foundation for future progress. A key way to achieve this is to work in tandem with organisations that are working locally to confront the nation’s most intractable local challenges. For example, Slum2School, an organisation that provides children in slums and remote communities in Lagos, Nigeria, to education. Last year, in the peak of the pandemic, the organization launched a digital platform that provides self-paced and collaborative learning modules delivered through interactive live sessions.

To address the poor learning levels pre-pandemic, and the learning losses induced by the pandemic, it is imperative to incorporate innovative measures to support and accelerate learning across schools in Nigeria. The role of education as a precursor to other Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) can not be denied, and unless the education system is strategically strengthened, progress on other goals/indicators will stagnate. The FACTS approach offers a basis upon which a results-driven, learning-oriented, inclusive and equitable strategy can be built.

This Article was first published on RISE

Read More

Will Nigeria’s Liquidity Shortage Morph into a Solvency Crisis?

In November of 2020, Zambia became the first African country to renege on its debt service obligations since the COVID-19 pandemic began. Since then, official and private lenders as well as governments have become apprehensive about a looming solvency crisis in Africa. This heightened perception of risk is underpinned by the fact that like Zambia, most countries on the continent are commodity dependent and have borrowed considerably from lenders that are reluctant in providing debt service suspension. Worse still, they are also experiencing a reduction in external financing from foreign direct investment, remittances, and development aid.   

Read More Download PDF

Regional Economic Integration can accelerate Africa’s Energy Transition

Energy production from non-renewable sources contributes significantly to total global greenhouse gas emissions. The emissions from the African continent are far less than from other regions. Yet, there is a worldwide consensus, through the Paris Agreement and the Agenda 2030, on the need to substantially increase the share of renewable energy and improve energy efficiency by 2030. Therefore, all countries that are signatories to the Paris Agreement are required to undertake a transition from fossil fuels such as oil and coal, towards renewable and environmentally friendly energy sources.

The main reason for this is environmental. But achieving reliable, sustainable and affordable energy is essential to reverse the vast energy supply shortages in Africa as well, such as catering to the growing population’s energy needs. Meeting the unmet energy demand can be a tool for economic growth, food security (by strengthening local agricultural resilience), and several other development outcomes.

Gaps and constraints to green energy development

Africa’s shift to green/renewable energy has been relatively sluggish compared to the global average. The slow adoption of green energy on the continent is attributed to many factors, among them:

  • Lack of finance: The International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) estimates that Africa’s transition to green energy would require an annual investment of $70 billion over the next 15 years. African countries, which are mostly low-income economies, have limited financial resources to fund such assets at the required scale.
  • Capacity deficits: The human and technical requirements of green energy production range from highly-skilled, technical elements (research and development, manufacturing), to medium and low skill elements (operation and maintenance). African countries face both a technical and human capacity constraint. Also, the appropriate technologies for exploiting available renewable energy sources are insufficient.
  • Fossil fuel subsidies: Fossil fuels are subsidised in many African countries. Such policies encourage its continuous use. Also, some renewable energy sources like hydropower are shared resources. This situation could limit its use for energy generation, in particular when intense competition exists with other sectors or among countries.

Read more on Southern Voice

Read More

Pandemic-related school closures were unprecedented – but they are not the biggest threat to children’s learning

While governments worldwide are continuing to struggle to implement forms of remote learning with equal access for all, the education crisis due to the COVID-19 pandemic is still being exacerbated globally. However, a recent landmark White Paper jointly issued by the world’s largest education organizations recall that this learning crisis isn’t really a new one.

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused unprecedented disruption to education systems worldwide. At the peak of the pandemic, approximately 1.5 billion learners globally were affected, with schools in many countries closed for months at a time to contain the spread of the virus.

Families, communities and school leaders across the world also suffered, trying to ensure that gaps in learning were minimized. Governments worldwide are continuing to struggle to implement forms of remote learning with equal access for all. The education crisis is being exacerbated globally.

However, a recent landmark White Paper jointly issued by the world’s largest education organizations highlights an important message: the learning crisis was always there.

The learning crisis

Before the pandemic, the World Bank’s Learning Poverty data estimates that 53 percent of students in low and middle-income countries lived in ‘learning poverty’ – defined as the number of 10 year olds in a country unable to read or understand a simple story in their language.

Recent projections by teams at UNESCO’s Institute of Statistics (UIS) and the World Bank’s Learning Poverty team have estimated that this number will rise due to the pandemic – by approximately 10 percent more.

Source: Education Commission, 2020.

Source: Education Commission, 2020. Out of the 53% of children in Learning Poverty, 44% are in-school children, who fail to meet minimum proficiency, and 9% are out-of-school children. The World Bank team estimates an additional 10% of children will enter learning poverty in 2020 due to the impact of COVID-19 pandemic closures. The team’s estimates are from their ‘pessimistic’ simulation projection.

The majority of these new additions to the population of learning poor are in fact from countries with relatively higher performing education systems. This is not because the education systems in these will suffer more from the impacts of the pandemic, but rather because the levels of learning are already so low in many low- and lower-middle income countries, that there is just less scope to reduce.

In the lowest-income countries, 90 percent of 10 years olds were already learning poorly.

The potential shock to funding for education

None of this means that the COVID-19 pandemic will not have a huge impact on the learning crisis – it undoubtedly will. The children who were already below the line of being able to read are likely to sink even deeper into learning deficits.

In addition, children in these contexts may suffer the most from the other impacts of school closures. For example, nutrition may be affected due to the loss of subsidized or free school meals, and other services children can access through school facilities.

However, the greatest long-term impacts on learning will likely be due to the ensuing financial crisis rather than directly as a result of school closures. The White Paper paints a bleak picture of rising costs for education systems, at a time when both domestic finance for education and international aid are at high risk of being cut.

The paper sets out the urgent need to close the financing gap for education globally, and to target funding to the most cost-effective approaches to deal with the fundamental systemic issues that caused the learning crisis to begin with.

Keeping focused on foundational learning

With the urgency surrounding rectifying the learning losses caused by the pandemic, there is also a risk that a focus will be on technology-enabled learning and children who are newly ‘learning poor’.

However, there is a risk that this will divert attention from the pre-pandemic learning crisis that already existed due to fundamental structural issues. There are no silver bullet solutions offered in this paper, and indeed there is a stark warning against the potential harm that unrealistic and unviable approaches to education technology can cause.

Instead, the paper strongly advocates for a focus on foundational learning driven by a renewed focus on the education workforce and on proven interventions such as differentiated instruction.

With this in mind, it is essential that policies and reforms not be reactionary and shortsighted. The unintended consequences of diverting attention away from the fundamental learning crisis will further widen the gaps of learning levels.

As political leaders grapple with ever more difficult trade-offs of solving the learning crisis, the hope is that they will heed this advice.

This blog was originally published on the GPE website and authored by by Myra Murad Khan, The World Bank, Kirsty Newman, Asian Development Bank, and Thelma Obiakor,  CSEA

Read More

DRAWing away from the curriculum of the past

A primary revelation in this pandemic-era world is the importance of digital readiness. While the pandemic is disrupting socio-economic activities, it is fortunately also happening at a time of rapid digitalisation, allowing economic players to respond and adapt to the situation accordingly. Swathes of the world are now operating largely online, allowing functional continuity as much as is possible, without personal interaction. However, differences in digital readiness across and within countries are hindering the ability of large segments of the world to co-opt and harness digital technology to cope with the COVID-19 pandemic. 

This inequality in digital readiness is reflected in Nigeria’s education sector, where learning was disrupted for almost 40 million learners nationwide. The digital infrastructure divide in Nigeria paints a bleak picture for the prospect of distance learning. With only about 40 percent of Nigeria having access to the internet, and 50 percent of the population having limited/no access to the electricity grid, the current prospects of digital technology for education during this crisis are slim. Beyond the infrastructure shortcomings, however, another problem threatens distance learning even more: The digital divide is more than just an infrastructure divide—it is also a literacy divide.

Digital Literacy

The nature and scope of digital literacy are so nuanced and complex that the term ‘digital literacy’, defies fixity and definition. For simplicity, in this article, I will use a definition provided by the American Library Association; ‘the ability to use information and communication technologies to find, evaluate, create, and communicate information, requiring both cognitive and technical skills’. In reality, it is a lot more complex, but the underlying fact is that at the most basic level, a digitally literate person is equipped with the digital-age skills required to effectively use technology and achieve valued output through it. This involves being able to connect to, safely navigate through, and benefit from internet services and applications. More functionally, it involves acquiring the skills that students and job seekers need to secure jobs and meet the needs of the modern digital economy. Investments in infrastructure development is crucial, but it is not a silver bullet; without a comprehensive effort to improve digital literacy through basic education, Nigerians (especially the disadvantaged and vulnerable) will be unable to fully leverage the potential of these investments. 

Current Basic Education Framework

The main goal of education is to prepare students for the demands of work and social life by equipping them with the skills to understand and address the core challenges/themes of the modern era. This means providing the skills and knowledge for students to solve the challenges of, and thrive in the age (time) they live in. 

Unfortunately, the basic education curriculum in Nigeria is not designed to provide students with the skills and knowledge in this modern digital economy. The traditional foundation of Nigeria’s basic education system consists of Reading, Writing and Arithmetic, colloquially known as the 3Rs. This foundation can be traced back to the 19th century, when the early Christian missionaries brought Western education into Nigeria (around 1843). This basic foundation was pertinent to developing the skilled workforce required by the industrial revolution. It was sewn into the fabric of Nigeria’s education system, and at the time, it was pertinent to us too. However, two centuries later, the skills-demand of the world has changed, and this change must be reflected in the foundation of our education system; as the skills-demand of the world is evolving, so should our education system. The current curriculum served well for the needs of the past, but the skills they offer will soon become obsolete. 

Technology is taking a greater role in our lives and everyday functioning, and digital literacy is becoming increasingly crucial to success. A student today needs to be able to do more than read, write and do basic arithmetic; they need to be equipped with skills that enable them to take on the challenges of the digital revolution, much like the 3Rs did for students of the industrial-age. Current conversations about incorporating digital learning into classrooms revolve around changing how teaching is done, with different recommendations for how to embrace and utilize technology for teaching and learning. However, to meet the demands of the digital economy, it requires changing not just how we teach, but also what we teach. Students need to be equipped with the skills to become both users and creators of technology. 

DRAW: A new framework

The pandemic presents a case for overhauling the basic education curriculum with the aim of adequately preparing the current and next generation of students. The entire 3Rs terminology is obsolete, and should itself evolve too. As a replacement, I propose DRAW: digital literacy, reading, arithmetic, and writing. 

  • DRAW incorporates digital literacy into the very core of Nigeria’s basic education, and emphasizes it as the channel through which the other three tenets of the curriculum will thrive. It retains the foundation of the 3Rs because, though digital tools are important, they will not be the only tools that students need. Incorporating digital literacy blends the arts and humanities with science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) fields, ensuring that all students are digitally equipped at the most basic level. 
  • As a word, DRAW immediately recognizes the importance of engendering an education system that sparks creativity (the highest order of learning) and problem-solving, and equips students to understand and express their knowledge in different ways. It provides equal weighting to the knowledge in the arts, humanities, and STEM fields, because it prioritizes digital knowledge as an educational tool through which students across all disciplines can analyse, interpret, create and communicate their ideas. DRAW ensures that all students are digitally equipped at the most basic level, harnesses technology to amplify the creativity and capabilities of students across all subjects, and enhances career prospects across all sectors/fields.

The ideal DRAW curriculum will be both current and futuristic in its design, and will advance a vision for students’ success in the new global economy. The digital literacy competencies would involve developing, en-masse and from a young age, an understanding of the machines and technologies that make the digital age possible. It includes (a non-exhaustive list) areas such as coding, cyber security, machine learning, computational thinking, robotics, and interface design. It is important to note that incorporating digital literacy is not simply about learning technology or digital tools for the sake of it. It involves engaging with the traditional and well established methods of understanding the world, and developing new insights and methods of the digital world and its potential impact on traditional core subject knowledge.

The details of this particular framework will require an in-depth analysis of Nigeria’s industrial needs, strengths, weaknesses and opportunities, in order to identify how to build a framework that positions us to be competitive in the digital global economy. And on a more holistic level, it would also require an in depth analysis of the financial and teacher qualification requirements. But largely, it will entail synthesizing current global themes (e.g, environmental literacy, global awareness, entrepreneurial literacy, social and cultural issues), digital literacies, and key life and work skills (e.g leadership, productivity initiative, flexibility accountability), into the training on traditional subjects, in order to reflect the evolving nature of subject knowledge. This addresses the fact that students will require a different form of knowledge and set of skills than generations before, in order to develop expertise and competitiveness in even the traditional subject areas. Ultimately, to ensure the successful marriage of the different features, teaching methods must inspire creativity, foster collaboration, motivate critical thinking, and support communication. 

Why is Digital Literacy Important? COVID-19 and the Future of Work

Prior to this pandemic, the future of work was already changing, but the pandemic has accelerated both the pace, need and uptake of technology. It has thrust us further into a digitized world, expediting the transition to the digital age by stimulating both the demand and supply-side of digital technology. Current adaptation strategies being incorporated to ensure continuity in the world of work, schooling, health and governance, are likely to persist even after economies world-wide have successfully reopened and start to recover. Intentional effort needs to be placed on preparing current and future students to succeed in this changing landscape. With the current curriculum, the average Nigerian student is ill-equipped to embrace and meet the demands of such a digitized world, so it is pertinent that we draw away from the curriculum of the past. 

On a national level, if we want to create a workforce that will be engaged and competitive in the digital economy, equal emphasis needs to be placed on developing skills as is on infrastructure. A key strategy will involve developing the skills to not just use technology, but also create innovative technology that can be used. On an individual level, in the post-COVID world, the phrase ‘leave no one behind’ will take on a different meaning in education. When students are not able to learn the skills they need to thrive in the new digitized economy, it creates a cohort of people who are unable to fully access and utilize digital services, are ill-equipped to meet the skills-demand of the world economy, are constantly steps behind the competition, and are caught in a pervasive web of incapability. 

This article was first published on Brooking Institute

Read More